Two fluoride-free xylitol toothpastes, two different strengths
If you are comparing Epic Toothpaste and Spry Peppermint, the first thing to notice is that both are fluoride-free xylitol toothpastes, but the supplied records emphasize different details. Spry highlights a low-abrasion range and SLS-free formula, while Epic highlights a specific xylitol percentage. That difference shapes which one may fit your routine better.
This comparison sticks to what the product records confirm. Where a detail is not supplied, such as a full ingredient list or RDA value for Epic, treat that as a limitation of the available information rather than a reason to assume anything about the product.
What each record confirms at a glance
- Spry Toothpaste Peppermint Fluoride Free: Fluoride-free, SLS-free, low abrasion range under 100 RDA, leaves cool fresh breath, made in the USA. Xylitol is the sweetener; the record notes it does not promote tooth decay and may reduce gum disease risk.
- Epic Toothpaste: Spearmint fluoride-free formula, 4.9 ounce size, at least 25% xylitol by total weight. The record notes xylitol does not promote tooth decay and may reduce gum disease risk.
Spry Peppermint: what the record says about abrasion and ingredients
- Spry Toothpaste Peppermint Fluoride Free: Low abrasion range < 100 RDA A stated RDA gives you a concrete reference point if you prefer a lower-abrasion toothpaste, especially for daily brushing.

Spry Toothpaste Peppermint Fluoride Free - Spry Toothpaste Peppermint Fluoride Free: SLS free and fluoride-free These are two common formulation preferences; the record confirms both for Spry Peppermint.
- Spry Toothpaste Peppermint Fluoride Free: Leaves cool, fresh breath This is the flavor expectation the record sets for the peppermint version.
Epic Toothpaste: what the record says about xylitol content
- Epic Toothpaste: Rich in xylitol (at least 25% of the total weight) This is the most specific xylitol figure in either record, so it matters if you want a toothpaste with a stated xylitol percentage.

Epic Toothpaste - Epic Toothpaste: Spearmint fluoride-free 4.9 ounce The record confirms the flavor, fluoride-free status, and size, which helps you compare routine fit.
- Epic Toothpaste: Xylitol is a sweetener that does not promote tooth decay and may reduce gum disease risk This is the shared xylitol claim in both records, so it does not separate the two products.
Where the records leave gaps
Spry Peppermint does not list a xylitol percentage in the supplied record, so you cannot compare xylitol content directly against Epic's at least 25%. Epic does not list an RDA or SLS status in the supplied record, so you cannot confirm low abrasion or SLS-free formulation for Epic from this information alone.
Neither record includes a full ingredient list, a fluoride concentration (both are fluoride-free), or preparation instructions. If you need those details, check the product packaging or ask the manufacturer before relying on this comparison.
How to choose between them
- Choose Spry Peppermint if you want a stated low-abrasion range and SLS-free formula: The record confirms both under 100 RDA and SLS-free, which are useful reference points if those are your priorities.
- Choose Epic Toothpaste if a stated xylitol percentage matters to you: Epic's record gives a specific figure (at least 25% of total weight), while Spry's does not.
- Choose based on flavor preference: Spry is peppermint; Epic is spearmint. Both records describe fresh breath or a cleaner mouth, so flavor is a personal tiebreaker.
- If you need both low abrasion and a xylitol percentage: Neither record confirms both for a single product, so you may need to check additional documentation or accept a tradeoff.
A note on xylitol claims
Both records state that xylitol does not promote tooth decay and may reduce the risk of gum disease. These are the claims as supplied; this article does not add or interpret them beyond that. For adults comparing fluoride-free toothpastes, the practical difference is in the formulation details each record confirms, not in the shared xylitol message.


